Three days had passed, and Caleb and Alys hadn't talked to each other since that night. They'd agreed not to seem like they were on good terms in public not to draw suspicion on matters of loyalty, and in between Emer punishing Caleb with bedrest and the way Alys had stormed off that night, he couldn't find a way or a reason to arrange another secret meeting. Because of that, when Caleb noticed the discrete twitch of her light blue wing earlier that afternoon he was surprised and even a little happy.
Caleb was good at sneaking around, but the cane made it harder than it had any right to be and he couldn't just fly down to the storage, with his wings contained to the narrow hallway. The hardest part was walking past Lucien's prisoner without making any noise that could possibly wake her up, and by the time he opened the gate to the livestock, about half an hour had passed from the time they'd agreed on.
"Are you in here, Starbird?" He called quietly, being welcomed with a goat's scream.
Alys' gaze rose from her lap; where in one hand, she held a piece of driftwood she'd taken from the beach in Allegria, and in the other, a small knife she'd nicked off a fellow crew mate. It wasn't the best knife for whittling, but it was small yet sturdy enough to get the job done. Thank the gods she'd brought her newest project along, else she'd have gone back to bed by now. Even then, it was a miracle she had stayed and waited this long, sitting in the near darkness among the livestock. She couldn't wait to hear his bullshit excuse, especially since during their last conversation, she had directly asked him if he thought she enjoyed wasting her own time. Apparently she did.
"Only Leo calls me that," she deadpanned quietly, after one of the goats had given him a more cheerful greeting. "Did you get lost on the way? Or are your injuries treating you well?"
Unlike their previous meeting, she had taken a seat in the very spot the quartermaster had occupied last time; with her back to the chickens, facing the goats. A lantern sat beside her, on the side further away from the door - to minimize the amount of escaping light.
"I didn't realize you were that close." Caleb said, holding back a smirk. He wanted to say he's a pirate, and pirates take things that don't belong to them, but Alys was clearly not in the mood for joking around. Perhaps it had something to do with waiting for him for a long time. "I'm sorry for wasting your time. I only have one functioning leg at the moment, y'know?"
With one hand on the cane, the other holding to the goat cage and one foot in the air, Caleb slowly slid down to sit across from Alys. Immediately a few goats flocked around him, sniffing his hair. So long as they only did that, they'd be fine.
He put the cane down by his side and looked up at Alys, the right side of her face glistening with candlelight. Afraid to say the wrong thing, he waited for her to speak, his eye trailing down from the glow in her hair to the wood piece in her hands.
A scoff escaped her lips. Close. There was certainly a meaning behind the name, something Leo had shared with her, so maybe Caleb was right. Maybe they were close. But it didn't matter much anyway, not when someone could steal it and make it their own.
"That sounds an awful lot like an excuse to me."
Forcing the emotion to roll off of her, like small, salty waves on the coastline, Alys leaned back and exhaled quietly, watching him. The fae didn't waver, not when she placed the piece of wood gently beside her, while her other hand fiddled with the knife. The pad of her thumb ran against the side of the blade, tempting fate. After he'd sat down, extending his legs toward her, somehow managing to make the space even smaller, Alys met his gaze. For a couple of seconds, they simply stared at each other in silence. Who would be the one to break first? More time passed, she pursed her lips, waiting. Then finally.
"I can be a true gentleman if I want to. You'd be surprised." Caleb said, holding eye contact. If Alys expected an apology for what had happened the other night she would be just as disappointed as his mother was the night he got arrested. "I'm assuming you didn't call me here because you missed me and wanted to know how I'm doing." He said, expecting she'd roll her eyes, maybe cuss him out, but get straight to the point. Alys was the one who'd called him there, and Caleb doubted she wanted to address the elephant in the room that made him too aware of how close his leg was to touching hers, the same elephant in his bedroom when he touched her cheek.
"Smart man," Alys retorted quietly, tilting her head slightly to the side, away from the flickering light.
Silence engulfed them, and she felt the mood shift away from what it was, to something a little more serious. It'd only been a day, but she'd thought about nothing else, only about Leo and his secret. And here she was, ready to reveal it to another. Not without thought, of course. The decision weighed heavily on her mind until her wings had twitched when she'd known that he would be watching.
Alys didn't want to be the only one who knew; she wanted someone to confide in, someone who would understand. And who better than the only other person on this ship with wings like hers? Wings like the ones Leo had plucked. It was almost poetic though, that he was also the person who she wanted to build trust with. As his eyes and ears, working together towards a greater goal.
Her gaze had lowered to her hands, which continued to fidget around with the carving knife. Forcing them to go still, she placed the blade on her knee and folded her hands together instead. "A little birdie told me something interesting last night..." she began, eyes meeting his. "I'm trusting you with this. Because Leo trusted me."
And so she told him. Starting with what had happened in Allegria, at the crepe stall, and ending with the conversation they had last night. About Leo's time with the aristocratic fae family, about his mistreatment, about the horrible details, about Sylvael and the babe - all of it. And when Alys was done, she felt a weight lift off her shoulders.
Her throat was dry, thirsty, from talking so much. Looking back down, she swallowed, then dragged her tongue against her lower lip. That's when she realized that at some point her hands had started fidgeting again. She was still nervous. "Sorry for unloading on you. Just... please don't say anything."To anyone else.
Caleb could tell by her reluctance that she had something important to say, so when Alys told him that he was being trusted with sensitive information, he nodded and listened quietly to the whole story.
The content was disturbing, yes, but not the most disturbing thing Caleb had ever heard. If he hadn’t years of violent memories and stories to dissociate from, perhaps he would have been just as distraught as Alys seemed to be. While the image of Leo ripping and biting away a fairy’s wings terrified her, Caleb saw it differently. He saw it as an opportunity.
Trust. Leo had told this to Alys in confidence, perhaps expecting her to keep it a secret, and he was in it now too. Sinead would’ve been disgusted if she ever heard there was so much trust going around her ship without her knowledge.
“I won’t say anything… But you will.” He said, noticing her nervous fingers before staring back at her eyes. “Lucien, Emer, Ciarán… They would never accept me as captain if I-” He didn’t finish the sentence, because he didn’t have to. “Someone else has to do it. And I think I know who, and how.”
His reaction, his words... they were unexpected. Unexpected despite not knowing what to expect. Perhaps that's why Alys' anxiety dissipated as other emotions clouded her mind, replacing that awful fear of vulnerability. Now, was it disappointment? Or merely anger? She felt anger the strongest of all, though not directed at him. No, she was angry with herself for giving in and expecting something else in return. But even as it bubbled within her, the faerie kept it contained to nothing more than a momentary tension in her jaw. Her breath left through her nose, quietly, calmly, and she found herself reaching for the piece of driftwood beside her. Her blade edged itself into the surface and she flicked a sliver off wordlessly. "What the fuck are you talking about?" She asked, voice quiet yet firm.
"I asked you to be my eyes and ears, and you have brought me information we can use." He answered, reminding her of why they were doing this in the first place. He told her about the compass that Sinead kept with her at all times, what they had used it for the first time and how he planned on using it again. "... And for that, I need the captain to sleep. And she will sleep if she gets a flashback."
It was low, he knew that and wasn't proud of it. He burrowed the guilt, reminding himself of what had to be done.
"When she gets bad ones Emer gives her something to sleep. She'll be passed out until morning."
That's right - eyes and ears, eyes and ears only. Alys clutched onto the reminder and buried everything else.
Disclosing someone else's secret had earned her enough trust for Caleb to share his plans. At some point she'd abandoned her project and found herself intently listening to the quartermaster, desperate to try to make sense of his plans, to make sense of how she'd gotten here. Once he was done, she tilted her head back and exhaled deeply.
"A million things can go wrong. Are you sure about this?" This was more than just watching and listening, it was more than just putting herself in danger. "I don't know if I can do it. I don't know if I can tell her," She said honestly, dipping her gaze down to her lap. It was a gamble on someone else's life.
A million things could go wrong, but Caleb already knew this when he chose this path. It was a risk he was willing to take, a risk with consequences he'd have to deal with after, if he survived.
"It's the last thing I'll ask of you." He said, pleading almost. "If I come back it means it worked. If not, you can go back to life as usual and nothing I've done will ever be traced back to you. It'll just be a weird coincidence." A shiver went up his spine as the thought of death - or worse - rushed over him. He chuckled nervously.
"If you're worried about Leo, don't be. Sinead won't hold his past against him, plus he won't have the strenght be upset with you for long."
Alys scoffed, barely able to suppress the desire to roll her eyes. "Didn't I tell you not to make me promises you can't keep?" This was just the beginning; she knew that, why didn't he? Had her part been anything short of invaluable? Did he really think that if the plan went just they wanted, that he'd be set? Without her? It was desperation - nothing else.
And for him to think that she'd just carry on as if nothing happened? As though he hadn't just waved a carrot in front of her, given her hope and desire for something more?
"You know Sinead better than anyone. So I'll trust your judgement when it comes to her. But Leo? I'll just be another faerie who's fucked him over."
But she knew he was going to go ahead with the plan with or without her. And their shot of success would be higher if she agreed.
With a defeated groan, Alys run a hand through her dirty blonde hair before meeting his gaze. "It'll need to be perfect. Because if you think you're going to leave me alone with them after I play my part, you're delusional." She could see it now; Caleb dead, leaving her alone with a Captain who can't stand what she was and an angry human with a history of wing mutilation. She'd be alone, the only fae. Alone with her guilt.
She wasn't just another fairy, and Leo was no longer a child. Caleb knew better than to outright say what the blonde had in her favor, and how easily a man like Leo would cave in with just a few tears - real or fake - streaming down those beautiful blue eyes. "You give me all the more reason to come back in one piece." Caleb said with a smile, pulling himself up to his left foot. They'd already been there a while, and it wouldn't be long until someone wondered about their whereabouts. He limped to the door and glanced back at Alys a final time before pushing it open, just slightly. "And you're right. I'll ask a lot more of you in the future, second-in-command."